ghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghgh
Rheumatoid Arthritis and Complementary and Alternative
Medicine
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic disease that affects the joints,
often those in a person's wrists, fingers, and feet. (Terms that are underlined
are defined "Definitions".) The common symptoms of RA are pain, stiffness,
fatigue, sleep disturbances, and fever. There are treatments for RA in
conventional medicine, but some people also try complementary and alternative
medicine (CAM). This report answers some frequently asked questions on this
topic and suggests sources for more information.
Key Points
It is very important for people with RA to ensure that (1) their RA was
diagnosed by a professional with substantial conventional medical training and
(2) their condition is being followed by a rheumatologist (a physician who
specializes in rheumatic diseases like RA). This is important to minimize damage
to the joints and bones, as well as disability.
There are many proven conventional treatments for RA. It is important not to
replace them with a CAM treatment that is unproven.
Many CAM therapies for arthritis are heavily advertised and make attractive
claims, often based on personal stories (testimonials). However, it is important
to find out whether any high-quality scientific research has been done on a CAM
therapy.
None of the CAM therapies discussed in this report have been proven to be of
benefit for RA. Some--such as thunder god vine (which is not currently available
in a safe American-made product), gamma-linolenic acid, fish oil, and mind-body
therapies--have shown some possibility of benefit for RA, but further studies
are needed to answer this question for sure.
It is important to tell your health care provider(s) about any CAM therapies you
are using or considering for RA. This is for your safety and a comprehensive
treatment plan.
What is rheumatoid arthritis (RA)?
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is what is called an autoimmune
disease. In this type of disease, a person's immune system (the system in the
body responsible for fighting disease) mistakenly attacks the person's own body.
In RA, the parts attacked are the linings of the joints (places in the body
where two bones connect). The reasons that this happens are complex and not
fully understood. RA causes pain, swelling, and stiffness in a person's joints
and problems with functioning. However, RA affects different people in different
ways, in terms of the symptoms they have, how serious the symptoms are, and how
long the symptoms last. RA is different from other types of arthritis (such as
osteoarthritis). For example:
-
RA usually occurs in a symmetrical pattern; for example, if
one hand is affected, usually the other will be, too.
- RA often affects the wrists and
fingers, though it can affect other parts of the body.
- RA is an autoimmune disease affecting
the entire body. A person with RA may feel tired and weak, have fevers at
times, lose appetite, lose weight, and generally not feel well.
To find out more about RA, contact the National Institute of
Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases.
How is rheumatoid arthritis treated in
conventional medicine?
There are many proven treatments in conventional medicine for
RA. They are used to relieve pain, reduce swelling, slow down or stop the damage
to joints, help the person function better, and improve the person's sense of
well-being. Medications include nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs),
disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs), biological response modifiers,
and corticosteroids. Non-drug treatments include physical therapy; modified
exercise programs; devices such as canes, special shoes, and splints (rigid
supports that keep a part of the body from moving while it heals); and lifestyle
changes--such as balancing activity with rest, eating a healthy diet, and
reducing stress. Scientific research is advancing in understanding the many
complexities of RA and in uncovering new and promising treatments.
It is important for people with RA to have their condition
followed by a rheumatologist (a physician who specializes in diseases of the
bones, muscles, and joints). This helps prevent or minimize damage to the joints
and disability, which can occur if RA is left untreated over time.
Why do some people with rheumatoid arthritis use CAM, and what
do they use?
Among the many reasons that some people use CAM for RA are:
P Because
conventional treatment is not working as well as they would like
P A wish for greater relief
of symptoms and/or disability
P Issues with side effects of
drug treatment
P A desire to reduce some of
the stress that comes from living with a chronic illness and to cope better
P A belief that CAM therapies
are safer and more "natural"
P Widespread advertising and
attractive claims for many CAM products
What CAM therapies for rheumatoid arthritis are discussed in
this report?
Many types of CAM are tried for RA, such as:
- Preparations made from botanicals (plants and their products, including
herbs)
- Vitamins and minerals in unconventional amounts
- Other products taken by mouth, such as fish oil
- Dietary approaches
- Preparations applied to the skin, such as balms and liniments
- Hydrotherapy
- Items that are worn (for example, magnetic clothing or copper bracelets)
- Mind-body therapies such as relaxation techniques, meditation, prayer for
health purposes, and tai chi
- Whole medical systems, such as Ayurveda (a traditional medicine of India),
traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, and
chiropractic
- Other therapies delivered by CAM practitioners--for example, acupuncture or
massage
Therapies Discussed in This Report
- Botanical supplements and other dietary supplements:
- Thunder god vine
- Gamma-linolenic acid (GLA)
- Fish oil
- Valerian
- Ginger
- Curcumin
- Boswellia
- Feverfew
- Glucosamine and chondroitin
- Special diets
- Acupuncture
- Magnets
- Hydrotherapy
- Homeopathy
- Selected mind-body techniques
>
What are some important points to keep in mind if I have
rheumatoid arthritis and am thinking about using CAM?
It is important to make sure you have been diagnosed with RA by a health care
provider who has substantial conventional medical training and experience with
arthritis patients. RA can be hard to diagnose, there is no single test for it,
and its symptoms can be similar to those of other conditions.
Proven conventional treatments for RA should not be replaced with a CAM
treatment that is unproven. This is especially important in the early stages of
RA, when researchers believe the most damage to joints and bones occurs.
Tell your health care provider(s) about any supplements or medications
(prescription or over-the-counter) that you are using or considering. Prescribed
medicines may need to be adjusted if you are also using a CAM therapy.
Supplements can interact with medications (whether prescription or
over-the-counter) and can affect how the body responds to them. Pharmacists can
also be a helpful source of information about dietary supplements (though their
advice is not a substitute for that of your provider).
If you decide to use supplements, what you see on the label may not reflect what
is in the bottle. For example, some botanical supplements have been found to be
contaminated with heavy metals or prescription drugs, and some have been found
to have much more or much less of the featured ingredient than their label
states. NCCAM has publications on these topics.
The claims for many CAM therapies can be attractive, ranging from enhancing
well-being, to helping with difficult chronic conditions, to achieving
unbelievable results. It is important to know whether scientific research has
proven that a therapy works and, if so, why.
Women who are pregnant or nursing, or people who are thinking of using CAM to
treat a child, should use extra caution and be sure to consult their health care
provider.
What is known from the scientific research about whether these
CAM treatments for rheumatoid arthritis are effective and safe?
- Botanical Supplements and Other Dietary Supplements
Overall, there is not much rigorous research available on the effectiveness and
safety of botanical and other supplements that people try for RA. It is also
important to know that while supplements are regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) as a category of foods, supplements made from plants and
used for medicinal purposes (sometimes referred to as herbal medicines) can have
effects as powerful as those of drugs. In fact, many conventional drugs first
came from plants, such as digitalis (from the foxglove plant), used to treat
heart failure and heart rhythm, and paclitaxel (from the yew tree), a cancer
chemotherapy drug.
It is important to be as informed as possible about the safety of any supplement
you are considering or using. Some information already exists from a long
history of botanical use outside conventional medicine. This knowledge is being
strengthened as NCCAM supports rigorous studies on botanicals and other
supplements that have shown promise in early studies to find out more about
their molecular structure, their safety, how they may work, and for what
diseases or conditions.
Thunder God Vine
Thunder god vine (TGV for short; botanical name Tripterygium wilfordii Hook F)
is a perennial vine native to China, Japan, and Korea. Preparations made from
the skinned root of TGV have been used in traditional Chinese medicine to treat
inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. Interestingly, TGV also has a history of
use to kill insects in farm fields.
Effectiveness and safety
Some anti-inflammatory and immune-system-suppressing activity for TGV has been
seen in laboratory and animal studies. The first clinical trial on TGV in the
United States (the earlier ones were done in China) was carried out at the
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and the National Institutes of
Health (NIH). Its results were published in 2002. Twenty-one patients for whom
conventional RA treatment had not worked completed the trial. Eighty percent of
those who received a high-dose TGV extract and 40 percent of those who received
a low-dose TGV extract experienced improvement in RA symptoms and physical
functioning. No one in the placebo group improved. Longer and larger studies are
needed to confirm these findings and to find out more about TGV.
Parts of the TGV plant are dangerous. The leaves, the flowers, the main stem,
and the skin covering the root are poisonous, to a point that they could cause
death. People should never try to make TGV medications themselves.
Currently, there are no consistent, high-quality TGV products being manufactured
in the United States. Preparations of TGV made outside the United States (for
example, in China) can sometimes be obtained, but it is not possible to verify
whether they are safe and effective. An expert from the University of Texas/NIH
study advises that consumers not use TGV until reliable TGV preparations become
available.
If taken for a long time (according to one study, for more than 5 years), TGV
may decrease the density of the minerals in women's bones, which would be of
special concern for women who have osteoporosis or are at risk for it. If taken
at high doses, TGV could suppress the immune system and increase the effects of
immune-suppressing drugs.
The TGV extract made for the NIH study discussed above was well tolerated by
study participants. However, side effects can occur and may include stomach
upset, diarrhea, skin rash, changes in menstrual periods, and hair loss.
Gamma-Linolenic Acid (GLA)
GLA is an omega-6 fatty acid that is found in the oils of some plant seeds,
including evening primrose (Oenothera biennis L.), borage (Borago officinalis
L.), and black currant (Ribes nigrum L.). GLA can be used by the body to make
substances that reduce inflammation.
Effectiveness and safety
A 2000 Cochrane Collaboration review analyzed seven placebo-controlled studies
of GLA (from evening primrose, borage, and black currant oils) for RA. The
authors noted there were issues with these studies that made it difficult to
draw conclusions. However, they thought the better studies indicated potential
relief for RA pain, morning stiffness, and joint tenderness.
There are potential side effects and risks to know about with GLA. First, these
plant seed oils may affect certain medical conditions and interact with
prescription medications. Specifically:
Some borage seed oil preparations contain ingredients called PAs (for
pyrrolizidine alkaloids) that can harm the liver or worsen liver disease. Only
preparations that are certified and labeled as "PA-free" should be used.
Borage oil and evening primrose oil might increase the risk of bleeding and
bruising, especially in people taking blood-thinning drugs, such as aspirin,
clopidogrel, NSAIDs, or warfarin.
Evening primrose oil may cause problems for people taking a class of psychiatric
drugs called phenothiazines, such as chlorpromazine or prochlorperazine.
Side effects of these oils can include nausea, diarrhea, soft stool, intestinal
gas, burping, and stomach bloating.
Fish Oil
Fish oil contains high amounts of two omega-3 fatty acids: EPA (eicosapentaenoic
acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid). As with GLA, the body can use omega-3s to
make substances that reduce inflammation.
Effectiveness and safety
There is some encouraging evidence from a number of laboratory studies, animal
studies, and clinical trials about the potential usefulness of fish oil or
omega-3 supplementation for various aspects of RA--such as the number of tender
joints, morning stiffness, and the need for NSAIDs. However, more research is
needed to definitively answer various questions, including what the most
effective dosage or length of treatment would be, which patients would benefit
most, and whether a placebo effect is at work.
In some people, the high amounts of omega-3s that are present in fish oil can
increase the risk of bleeding or affect the time it takes blood to clot. If a
person is taking drugs that affect bleeding or is going to have surgery, this is
of special concern. Fish oil supplements interact with medicines for high blood
pressure, so taking them together might lower a person's blood pressure too
much.
Certain species of fish can contain high levels of contaminants, such as
mercury, from the environment. Thus, their oils could pose a health risk,
especially for pregnant or nursing women and for children. The fish that the
Federal Government has found to have the highest levels of mercury are shark,
swordfish, king mackerel, and tilefish. People who decide to use fish oil should
look for products made from fish with lower mercury levels. Government
information on this topic is available.d You may have to contact the
manufacturer to find out the type(s) of fish used in a product. Also, it is
desirable to find out whether the manufacturer tests the product for
contaminating substances and if the results of those tests are available.
Another point to note about safety is that a product called fish liver oil can
contain more vitamin A than the recommended daily dosage, which could cause
problems.
Generally, for low doses of fish oil supplements, the side effects are mild and
can include a fishy aftertaste, belching, stomach disturbances, and nausea.
dTwo Federal publications are "Mercury Levels in Commercial Fish and Shellfish"
and "What You Need to Know About Mercury in Fish and Shellfish: Advice for Women
Who Might Become Pregnant, Women Who Are Pregnant, Nursing Mothers, and Young
Children" are available online. They are copublished by the U.S. Department of
Health and Human Services and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
Valerian
The herb valerian has a history of use for sleep problems and anxiety disorders.
Disrupted sleep has been called a common and often neglected symptom of
arthritis. A large, nationally representative survey of people over 65 with
arthritis in 2000 found that disruption of sleep, among all the disruptions of
arthritis, was the main reason that people sought a variety of CAM, self-care,
and conventional medical treatments. Valerian has also been taken for other
reasons, such as the intent to relieve muscle and joint pain. The species of
valerian most used in American supplements is Valeriana officinalis.
Effectiveness and safety
The evidence suggests that valerian has at least mild benefits for sleep
problems in the general population, including insomnia. It has been theorized
that valerian may have benefit for people with sleep problems from RA. However,
research on valerian for RA specifically has not been done to answer this
question.
There is not much evidence on how long it is safe to take valerian and which
dose to use.
There is not enough reliable evidence to declare whether valerian is effective
for muscle and joint pain, including pain from RA. There may be some biological
basis for the theory that valerian could be beneficial for musculoskeletal pain.
Valerian is considered generally safe. However, it should not be taken with
sedative drugs (for example, alcohol, benzodiazepines, or narcotics) or other
sedative herbs (such as melatonin, SAMe, or St. John's wort). Valerian will
increase sedative effects. People who are taking antifungal drugs, statins, or
certain anti-arrhythmia drugs should not take valerian. Valerian may not be safe
for people who have a liver disorder or are at risk for one. After taking
valerian, caution should be used in driving or using dangerous machinery. Side
effects of valerian can include drowsiness in the morning, headache, stomach
problems, excitability or anxiety, and sleeplessness.
Four Other Botanicals
Three of the other botanicals marketed with claims to benefit arthritis pain
are:
Ginger
Curcumin (a component of the spice turmeric)
Boswellia (also called Indian frankincense, made from the resin of a tree that
grows in India)
These three botanicals have a history of use in Ayurveda to treat inflammatory
conditions. Based on some early findings that may indicate promise, NCCAM is
supporting studies at the University of Arizona on these three botanicals, to
increase scientific knowledge about them and determine whether they are helpful
for chronic inflammatory conditions such as arthritis and asthma.
A fourth botanical, feverfew, has been used in folk medicine with an intent to
treat arthritis, migraine, and other conditions. One small published clinical
trial was located for this report. It found no more benefit from feverfew than
from the placebo. Overall, feverfew has not been proven to help RA symptoms.
Safety
Ginger's possible side effects include stomach upset, diarrhea, and irritation
to the mouth and throat. Ginger is not recommended for people who have a
bleeding disorder, a heart condition, or diabetes. Ginger may further slow blood
clotting when combined with other herbs and drugs that slow blood clotting; add
to the blood-pressure-lowering effects of drugs for high blood pressure and
heart disease; and add to the blood-sugar-lowering effects of diabetes drugs.
Curcumin can have side effects of stomach problems, including nausea and
diarrhea. Curcumin could add to the effects of other herbs and drugs that slow
blood clotting. Curcumin can cause gallbladder contractions and should not be
used by people with gallbladder disease or gallstones.
Boswellia can have side effects of stomach pain, stomach upset, nausea, and
diarrhea. It is not known whether boswellia interacts with any drugs,
supplements, or diseases and conditions.
Feverfew appears to be safe for short-term use, but the safety of long-term use
is not known. Feverfew can cause an allergic reaction, especially in people who
are allergic to the daisy family. Side effects can include diarrhea and other
stomach upsets. Chewing fresh leaves of feverfew may cause mouth irritation and
sores. Feverfew might interact with medications broken down by the liver and
increase the actions of drugs that slow blood clotting. Pregnant women should
not take feverfew.
Glucosamine and Chondroitin
Glucosamine sulfate (glucosamine for short) and chondroitin sulfate (chondroitin)
are popular dietary supplements for arthritis. They are sold separately, in
combination with each other, and in other combinations.
Glucosamine is a substance found in the fluid around the joints. It can also be
obtained from the shells of shrimp, lobster, and crabs, or made in the
laboratory. The body uses glucosamine to make and repair cartilage, a firm but
flexible tissue that covers the ends of bones, keeps them from rubbing against
each other, and absorbs the force of impact.
Chondroitin is a substance found in the cartilage around joints. As a
supplement, it is obtained from sources such as sharks and cattle.
Effectiveness and safety
Both glucosamine and chondroitin have shown anti-inflammatory effects in animal
studies. In humans, they have been studied only for osteoarthritis so far, not
for RA. Osteoarthritis is a different form of arthritis than RA, with different
causes, although the symptoms are similar (such as joint pain and problems with
function). One cannot assume that if a treatment is helpful for one type of
arthritis, it will also be helpful for another type. The studies of glucosamine
and chondroitin for osteoarthritis mostly found a modest benefit. However, some
design flaws have been noted in those studies. In sum, there is no evidence that
glucosamine and chondroitin are helpful for RA.
Glucosamine appears to be safe for most people. However, it might worsen asthma
through an allergic reaction. Also, glucosamine might cause higher blood sugar
and insulin levels in people with diabetes, and those who decide to use it need
to carefully monitor their blood sugar. Glucosamine could possibly decrease the
effectiveness of certain medications--acetaminophen, some anticancer drugs, and
antidiabetes drugs. Generally, side effects of glucosamine can include mild
stomach problems and nausea; less commonly, there can be sleepiness, a skin
reaction, or a headache. Some people who are allergic to shellfish are concerned
about an allergic reaction to glucosamine. However, most shellfish allergies are
to proteins in the meat, not to the shell material from which glucosamine
supplements are made.
Chondroitin appears to be safe for most people. However, chondroitin may
possibly worsen asthma (through an allergic response), blood clotting disorders,
and prostate cancer. The side effects of chondroitin can include stomach pain
and nausea; less commonly, diarrhea, constipation, swelling, and problems with
heart rate.
Both supplements could affect the action of the drug warfarin, but this is not
definite.
- Special Diets
Many people with RA are interested in whether certain foods can affect their
symptoms. Examples of foods that are believed to possibly worsen the symptoms of
arthritis (including RA) are the nightshade family of plants (white potatoes,
tomatoes, eggplant, and peppers), dairy, citrus fruits, acidic foods, sweets,
coffee, and animal protein. There are various theories about how foods may
affect RA, including:
The foods one eats and how the digestive system handles them are known to affect
the immune system. Because RA is a disease of the immune system, a connection
between diet and the disease has been proposed.
Certain fats (mostly from animal sources, but also from corn and sunflower oils)
break down in the body into substances that can cause inflammation.
RA and/or medications to treat it may affect the way a person's digestive system
handles foods.
RA can affect a person's ability to prepare and eat food, leading to nutritional
problems.
Effectiveness and Safety
There is no strong, reproducible evidence that any foods or diets have a
specific role in causing or treating RA.
It is important for people who have RA to eat a healthy, balanced diet.
If one or more foods are eliminated from the diet, it is possible to miss key
nutrients and not get enough calories. It is important to discuss any major
dietary changes with your health care provider or a registered dietitian.
A true food allergy may exist in a small percentage of patients with RA. Many
people think they have food allergies when they do not have them or when they
have a different condition called food intolerance. To find out more, see the
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases in "For More Information."
- Acupuncture
Acupuncture is a practice that developed as a part of traditional Chinese
medicine. Some people try acupuncture to treat RA pain or to treat the RA
itself. For more about acupuncture, see NCCAM's fact sheet "Acupuncture."
Effectiveness and Safety
Good research studies have shown that acupuncture can help relieve pain
associated with osteoarthritis. However, not much is known about its
effectiveness for symptoms of RA. A handful of small studies have been
conducted, and the findings do not clearly answer this question. Issues with the
studies have included design problems, a small number of participants,
variations in where acupuncture was given on the body, and how many treatments
were given and for how long. More and better research is needed.
Acupuncture tends to have minimal side effects, if any. Relatively few
complications from acupuncture have been reported to the FDA. If a person
decides to use acupuncture, it is important to find a licensed and certified
practitioner, as any complications have usually occurred from inadequate
practitioner training and experience.
- Magnets
Magnets are objects that produce a type of energy called magnetic fields. The
term "magnets" is also used to refer to consumer products that contain magnets.
Examples include shoe insoles, clothing, wraps for parts of the body, and
mattress pads. These are of a type called static magnets, because their magnetic
fields are unchanging.
Effectiveness and Safety: Static Magnets
The research so far does not firmly support claims that static magnets are
effective for treating pain, including pain from RA. In those cases where some
benefit was seen, it has not been proven why; many scientists think it may be
due to a placebo effect. If someone does experience a benefit from a magnet, it
will tend to occur quickly.
Static magnets should not be used by pregnant women; people who have a
condition--such as an acute sprain, inflammation, infection, or wound--that
could be affected by dilation of the blood vessels; and people who use a device
such as a pacemaker, defibrillator, or insulin pump, or who use a medication
patch.
The second type of magnets used for health purposes are called electromagnets (EMs),
because they produce magnetic fields only when electric current flows through
them. EMs are used in conventional medicine to treat bone fractures that have
not healed well, and they are being studied in research settings for a number of
other conditions (including cancer, epilepsy, RA, and mental disorders). Some
consumer products using EMs are available.
Effectiveness and Safety: Electromagnets
EMs are being studied because there have been some encouraging early findings
indicating the possibility of benefits for pain, physical function, and
stiffness. However, it is too early to know for sure whether EMs are of benefit
for patients with RA.
EMs should not be used by pregnant women; people who have a condition--such as
an acute sprain, inflammation, infection, or wound--that could be affected by
dilation of the blood vessels; and people who use a device such as a pacemaker,
defibrillator, or insulin pump, or who use a medication patch. It may be
advisable for people who have a history of cancer or seizure disorder to avoid
using EMs until more is known about their effects on these medical conditions.
For more about magnets, see the NCCAM fact sheet "Questions and Answers About
Using Magnets To Treat Pain."
- Hydrotherapy
Hydrotherapy is the use of water for therapeutic purposes. A few examples of
hydrotherapy include bathing in heated water, as from hot springs or the sea;
mineral baths; and water-jet massages. Another term used for hydrotherapy baths
is balneotherapy.
Hydrotherapy dates back to ancient Greece and Rome. In recent centuries, it has
been a popular treatment in Europe and Israel. Some forms of hydrotherapy are
used in conventional medicine in the United States, such as whirlpool baths for
athletic injuries and ice for sprains. As CAM, hydrotherapy is often combined
with other treatments, such as exercises, massage, diets, herbs, and/or mud
packs. It is used with the intent to benefit arthritis, circulation, and various
other health issues, and to enhance feelings of relaxation and well-being. Some
also claim that hydrotherapy "detoxifies" the body. In this report, the term
hydrotherapy refers to external water treatments and not to internal treatments
using water, such as colon irrigation or drinking specially treated water.
Effectiveness and Safety
A small number of controlled studies have been done on hydrotherapy for RA, most
based on sea-bath treatments given in Israel's Dead Sea area. Most of these
studies reported benefit. However, there have been quality issues noted with
these studies, and it is not considered proven that the hydrotherapy itself
provided the benefits for RA claimed in these studies. Larger and better studies
are needed to answer this question. Study authors have noted that there could be
other reasons for any benefit, such as traveling to a spa, being removed from
one's daily routine, relaxation, socializing, etc.
The safety of hydrotherapy has not been well studied. Overall, it appears to be
a low-risk practice for most people if common-sense precautions are taken, such
as not exposing the body to too much heat or cold or for too long a time, and
being sure to drink enough fluid. However, hydrotherapy is riskier and could
even be dangerous for certain people:
Those who have a condition that could be worsened by exposure to extremes of
heat or cold (for example, heart disease, lung disease, circulation disorder,
Raynaud's phenomenon, or chilblains) or by strong motions from water jets
Those who have difficulty perceiving temperature (for example, from neuropathy,
or damage to the nerves)
Women who are pregnant
People who have implanted medical devices such as pacemakers or pumps
Some people may get a skin irritation or infection from hydrotherapy water,
either as a reaction to something in the water or if the water is not in
sanitary condition.
- Homeopathy
Homeopathy is a whole medical system that was developed in Germany and brought
to the United States in the 19th century. Homeopathy involves giving very small
doses of substances called remedies that would produce the same or similar
symptoms of illness in healthy people when given in larger doses. This approach
is called "like cures like." The remedies are diluted very highly, often to a
point where not one molecule of the original substance remains. For more about
homeopathy, see NCCAM's fact sheet "Questions and Answers About Homeopathy."
Effectiveness and Safety
Little rigorous research has been done on homeopathy for RA. The results have
been mixed. It appears from some studies that homeopathy might be more effective
than a placebo for rheumatic diseases and syndromes (including RA), but this
evidence is not strong. Larger, better-designed studies are needed to resolve
this question.
Homeopathic remedies are considered safe and unlikely to cause severe side
effects. The FDA has learned of a few reports of illness associated with the use
of these remedies, but determined that the remedies were not likely to be the
cause. Homeopathic remedies are not known to interfere with conventional drugs.
- Selected Mind-Body Techniques
Mind-body techniques draw upon the interactions that exist in health and disease
between the mind, the emotions, the body as a whole, and various body systems
(such as the immune, nervous, and endocrine systems). Some mind-body techniques
are part of ancient healing traditions, others have emerged in recent times.
Examples of mind-body techniques include meditation, tai chi, relaxation
techniques, and spirituality for health purposes.
Effectiveness and Safety
Mind-body therapies have been applied to and studied for various types of pain.
Results from clinical trials indicate that mind-body therapies may be effective
additions to the treatment and management of arthritis, including RA and its
pain.
One analysis of clinical trials on mind-body therapies for RA has been
published. These authors, who evaluated 25 trials and published their findings
in 2002 also concluded that mind-body approaches may be effective additions to
RA treatment. They noted that mind-body practices led to significant
improvements in RA pain, disability, overall psychological state (psychological
status), coping, and belief in one's own ability to handle situations
(self-efficacy). Mind-body therapies appeared to be more helpful for people who
had RA for a shorter period of time, not a longer period.
There are still questions about mind-body therapies and RA that need to be
answered by research, such as which among these therapies are most effective
and, if they work, how they work.
Spirituality may help people with RA in their quality of life, coping, and how
they feel about their health, although the research so far has been limited, and
often it has not looked at RA only. A 2003 study at Johns Hopkins University of
people with moderate RA found that those who had "spiritual transcendence"e had
more happiness, joy, and positive perceptions of their own health. This was
regardless of how severe their RA was or how well they could function.
There have been some small studies on tai chi for RA. Tai chi is a practice from
traditional Chinese medicine that uses specific postures along with gentle, slow
movements; meditation; and coordinated breathing. These studies on RA have had
conflicting results; some found improvement in daily functioning and certain
symptoms, others did not. NCCAM is co-sponsoring a clinical trial that compares
tai chi chih (a type of tai chi) to relaxation therapy for symptoms of RA. An
earlier clinical trial by this team found tai chi chih improved physical
functioning and immunity in healthy older adults. Other research as well has
supported benefit from tai chi to older people on such outcomes as balance,
postural stability, frailty, and prevention of falls. Tai chi is a relatively
safe practice. It is done slowly and at low impact to the body.
In mind-body therapies, there are relatively few physical and emotional risks,
if any. A helpful aspect of most mind-body therapies is that they can be taught
to users and practiced by them at times and places of their choice.
___________________________________________________________________________________________
Article reviewed and edited by Don Stewart, RPh at ShopNaturalHealth.Net
SOURCE: National Center for
Complementary and Alternative Medicine